Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Potsie digs Russell Crowe's cross-dressing flick, CINDERELLA MAN!

Hey folks, Harry here with a fella I'll call Potsie and his look at Ron Howard's CINDERELLA MAN! We've had pretty damn strong word of mouth on this film since late November of last year when it began its test screening process. There have been a couple of bad reviews, but mostly positive... Now the thing that kind of drives me crazy is the whole SEABISCUIT / CINDERELLA MAN comparison that cynical critics seem to be bringing up in their Summer preview pieces. It's like the KINGDOM OF HEAVEN / GLADIATOR comparisons. Folks... that one drove me insane. For one - the periods are separated by over a 1000 years, the plots are totally different... and all the actors are different. With SEABISCUIT and CINDERELLA MAN... well at least you have the same period and a come from behind competitor going on. But Russell Crowe isn't some silent blank-eyed horse, he's one of the best actors working today - and the story of Jim Braddock is a very HUMAN story set in the depression. Personally - I love a good boxing movie. This sounds like one!

Hey Harry. I’ve sent you a couple first look reviews earlier this year with some very negative remarks on SON OF THE MASK and a disappointing experience with this week’s KICKING AND SCREAMING. Well, this time I’m happy to report I have an early look at Ron Howard’s latest, CINDERELLA MAN. This is the true story of boxer Jim Braddock and his struggles with his wife and three young children through the great depression.

In what has so far been a dreadful year for movies, CINDERELLA MAN is like a breath of fresh air for moviegoers of all kinds. We’ll see what the rest of the year has to bring, but so far this is the only serious Oscar contender I can think of. Whether you like it or not, this is the kind of movie that voters love to honor. It is likely to snag nominations for Picture, Director, Actor, Supporting Actress, Supporting Actor, Cinematography, Costume and Screenplay. But then again it’s only May, and from the few dozen movies I have seen so far in 2005 I will tell you this, they can only get better.

I’ll start off with Russell Crowe (Braddock). To me, this performance confirms that Crowe is one of a handful of actors that has the right to demand any ridiculous sum of money that he wants. Chris Rock was right at the Oscars “If you can’t get Russell Crowe, wait!” I don’t care how much of an asshole this guy is on his days off, he knows the job and he nails it with every performance. His portrayal of Braddock is flawless as the kind of antagonist we love to follow, a real movie hero that the audience can identify with. The there is Renee Zellwegger as Braddock’s supportive, though often disapproving wife. I’ll tell you right off the bat that I am not a huge fan of hers. Something about her squinty eyes, baby voice and swollen cheeks make me want to turn the other way. Sometimes she is passable and other times I just want her to go away. All in all, I don’t think she is very good loo

Then there is Paul Giamatti as Braddock’s manager. Now I have been a fan of his ever since he first came into the public’s eye as “Pig-Vomit” in Howard Stern’s PRIVATE PARTS. Here, he is still reduced to somewhat of the same wisecracking sidekick role, but in all honesty nobody does it better. I was skeptic about his work in SIDEWAYS as the leading man. I actually pretty much forget about that movie all together. (A little overrated, don’t ya think?) Anyways, Giamatti does here, what he does best without ever attempting to chew up the scenery. Those of you upset about his nowhere to be found Oscar nomination last year should feel pretty confident that he will not go unrecognized next January when the nominations are announced.

And then there is Ron Howard, who I can officially forgive for THE GRINCH. He really handles this story with great grace and maturity. This is your standard bio-pic, but it never feels like it. We never need to see how Braddock was raised or how he met his wife. This is a piece of a man’s life displayed through vision and sound with the utmost cinematic pleasures. And unlike a lot of epic filmmakers, Howard wraps it up nicely in just a little over two hours. *(Take out the little training montage at the halfway mark that we could do without, and every scene feels necessary). The boxing scenes alone, which make up about thirty percent of the film are among the most exciting we have seen in any sports movie in recent memory. There is more excitement in the last twenty minutes of this movie than any other I have seen all year.

Some, looking for something negative to say about this, will complain that the movie is too sentimental. But I never thought that. We don’t get a lot of sweeping music or tears to manipulate us. Everything about it is pure and true to the spirit of Braddock’s personality. And then there will surely be comparisons to MILLION DOLLAR BABY, another “kind of” boxing movie. Both movies are great, but really can’t be compared. I urge people to see it only because it will tell studios we want to see more movies like it. We want more reasons to go to the theaters. Remember, if we keep shelling out our dough to see lackluster stuff like HITCH and SAHARA, they will just make more of them. Why do you think we got XXX: STATE OF THE UNION?

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

It's not that KoH is like Gladiator...
by chrth
May 13th, 2005
03:17:18 PM
Again?
by Jaffa8
May 13th, 2005
03:17:40 PM
nope...
by Jaffa8
May 13th, 2005
03:18:02 PM
Russell Crowe is the Sexiest Tomboy Bean Pole on the Planet
by John-Locke
May 13th, 2005
03:18:16 PM
hollywood is so in love with making movies that take place in th
by HypeEndsHere
May 13th, 2005
03:19:54 PM
Can't be worse than Million Dollar Baby
by John-Locke
May 13th, 2005
03:24:57 PM
Hmmm....
by godric
May 13th, 2005
03:37:26 PM
Saw this a couple of weeks ago
by Shawn F.
May 13th, 2005
03:45:51 PM
Hillary Swank...
by MattCG
May 13th, 2005
03:46:30 PM
Russell Crowe is a Stooge.
by DR mandrake
May 13th, 2005
04:07:33 PM
"... one of the best actors working today "
by Bean_
May 13th, 2005
04:30:31 PM
I'd see this movie if at the end he boxed Seabiscuit
by InspectorDoppler
May 13th, 2005
04:44:46 PM
Malformed Stub of Cock
by Negator76
May 13th, 2005
04:53:02 PM
Hey, Lock: It's not "youth in Asia." It's "euthenasia."
by Barry Egan
May 13th, 2005
04:54:39 PM
I agree with Harry
by AeroB
May 13th, 2005
04:59:49 PM
Who cares if Crowe is an asshole!?!?!?!??
by Barry Egan
May 13th, 2005
05:03:11 PM
Re:Barry Egan. I was trying to keep it spoiler free if you aint
by John-Locke
May 13th, 2005
05:04:52 PM
Boxing
by crold1
May 13th, 2005
05:18:36 PM
"This is the standard bio-pic..."
by Theta
May 13th, 2005
05:26:31 PM
I saw this movie when it was called Seabiscuit
by Vetch108
May 13th, 2005
05:31:55 PM
Originality is lost
by Sagitaurus
May 13th, 2005
05:49:12 PM
Hillary Swank has the chops, or, choppers, to play Nancy Kerriga
by eraser_x
May 13th, 2005
05:58:41 PM
Barry Egan, you and Locke are both wrong
by eraser_x
May 13th, 2005
06:02:34 PM
This crowd has gone deadly silent, a Cinderella story outta nowh
by JAGUART
May 13th, 2005
06:03:08 PM
Akiva Goldsman
by Gheorghe Zamfir
May 13th, 2005
06:06:04 PM
This will be the most overrated movie since A Beautiful Mind.
by Rant Breath
May 13th, 2005
08:08:10 PM
When American was on its knees, Hitler brought us to our feet!
by eraser_x
May 13th, 2005
08:18:51 PM
oops. good points, sparklecopy, except the one about pillaging
by eraser_x
May 13th, 2005
08:21:33 PM
but you know who did pillage?
by eraser_x
May 13th, 2005
08:43:44 PM
The Red Army
by kuryakin
May 13th, 2005
09:32:03 PM
"Those of you upset about his nowhere-to-be-found Oscar nominati
by Ribbons
May 14th, 2005
01:48:57 AM
About "pillaging"
by Ribbons
May 14th, 2005
01:56:54 AM
JewJewBoy
by Ribbons
May 14th, 2005
02:11:16 AM
Dear Ribbons, it was literally impossible to steal katanas from
by eraser_x
May 14th, 2005
02:24:32 AM
Dear eraser_x, I'm pretty sure that I have this on good informat
by Ribbons
May 14th, 2005
02:29:45 AM
good points about the Soviets and their Red Army, kuryakin
by eraser_x
May 14th, 2005
02:38:03 AM
Ribbons, I'm not doubting the facts of your story,
by eraser_x
May 14th, 2005
02:49:17 AM
"...which makes bush no better than Hitler..."
by AeroB
May 14th, 2005
05:35:47 AM
"Butchered in one of those towers on sept 11th"
by eraser_x
May 14th, 2005
06:03:09 AM
eraser_x
by Ribbons
May 14th, 2005
12:02:52 PM
No, Kirk Douglas' heir is Mickey Rourke
by njg122
May 15th, 2005
03:43:23 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.