|
Published on Tuesday, September 14, 1999 - 2:28am |
|
Pathall looks over BUT I'M A CHEERLEADER, THE LIMEY and THE CIDER HOUSE RULES at the Toronto Film Festival
Hey folks, Harry here. I've actually been quite looking forward to BUT I'M A CHEERLEADER. Being a long time fan of the cheerleader genre (PRETTY MAIDS ALL IN A ROW, REVENGE OF THE CHEERLEADERS and THE SWINGING CHEERLEADERS being just three) So... while Pathall here enjoyed the film but didn't love it, it gives me hope. Hopefully it'll be coming to Austin soon. Well, here's Pathall...
Pathall Here reporting in as ordered! I've only got time for some brief reviews, so I will hop right to it.
Other Festival movie ratings for comparison:
AMERICAN BEAUTY 9/10
HUMAN TRAFFIC 7/10
BUT I'M A CHEERLEADER w/Natasha Lyonne, Clea Duvall, RuPaul; dir. Jamie Babbit.
A comedy about a cheerleader (Lyonne) sent away to a "homosexual rehab camp"
by her straightlaced parents. Possibly a controversial subject, which this
movie handles strictly for laughs -- such "rehab" is patently impossible,
so what would really happen if you put a bunch of gay teenagers together?
The director Jamie Babbit was at the screening (the world premiere!) and
mntioned that she grew up in an alcohol rehab camp run by her mother, and
wanted to do a comedy about life in such a camp. She succeeds with a funny
movie, but it does suffer in comparison to other festival movies I've seen
so far; it's amusing but not particularly original and the acting is a bit
stiff in places. Still, worth seeing if you want a simple comedy. 6/10.
PS Yet another example of the incomprehensibility and double standards of
the MPAA: the director said they had her cut references to female oral sex
to get an R, but that references to & suggestions of male oral sex were OK.
THE LIMEY w/Terence Stamp, Peter Fonda, Lesley Ann Warren, Luis Guzman;
dir. Steven Soderbergh; written by Lem Dobbs (DARK CITY, KAFKA)
An outstanding performance by Terence Stamp as a British ex-con who comes
to LA to discover the truth behind his daughter's "accidental" death. Peter
Fonda and frankly everyone else in the film turn in excellent performances
as well. It was introduced as a "tight, taut" film, which I thought meant
"fast-paced" but which really meant that it's a very focused character study
of Stamp's character, the Limey. But the movie also makes use of flashbacks,
flashforwards, quick cuts, acting out of the Limey's thoughts, etc., which
make it very distinctive. Terence Stamp (at the screening along with
Soderbergh) said that to get such and excellent part "this late in my career"
was a minor miracle. But his performance shows it's a deserved miracle. 8/10.
THE CIDER HOUSE RULES w/Tobey Maguire, Michael Caine, Delroy Lindo,
Erykah Badu, Charlize Theron; dir. Lasse Hallstrom; screenplay by John Irving
from his novel.
An excellent, beautifully filmed story of the young orphan Homer Wells (Maguire)
growing up in Maine in the 1940s. Dr. Larch (Caine), who runs the orphanage,
treats him as a son and teaches him medicine. The doctor also performs illegal
abortions, of which Homer disapproves. Another potentially controversial
subject, which the movie does a good job of handling by having two characters
who disagree but do so in a civil manner, both making their cases and doing
what they feel is right. Eventually Homer decides to leave the orphanage,
getting a job picking apples with a group of migrant workers (Lindo, Badu, and
featuring Heavy D as "Peaches") and getting involved with Candy (Theron) while
her boyfriend is off at war. I don't know if John Irving is happy with his
adaptation of his novel and the filming of it, but I certainly was, and the
very good performances (esp. Maguire) and excellent direction of Hallstrom put
it over the top. Take your folks to see it during the holidays. 8/10
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reader Talkback
I'm first? by Indy2 | Sep 14th, 1999 05:34:52 AM | she's a hack by MadBoy | Sep 14th, 1999 06:42:50 AM | A Hack?!? by Scud-0 | Sep 14th, 1999 07:13:32 AM | Matthew Modine! by Pope Buck 1 | Sep 14th, 1999 07:15:34 AM | Scud-O. . . by MadBoy | Sep 14th, 1999 08:19:22 AM | The Limey and Cider House
Rules by Vicki | Sep 14th, 1999 11:16:36 AM | MPAA Disgusted by All Thumbs | Sep 14th, 1999 12:13:36 PM | Cider House Rules by filmzeus | Sep 14th, 1999 07:24:32 PM | in defense by ccbaxter | Sep 14th, 1999 09:04:23 PM | You Neglected To Mention.... by Shemp | Sep 14th, 1999 09:43:49 PM | limey cheerleader in the cider
house by pathall | Sep 15th, 1999 01:01:45 PM | "Terence Stamp"? Not likely... by narf | Sep 15th, 1999 01:11:30 PM | Terrence Stamp - new from the
US Postal Service. by Wolfpack | Sep 6th, 2006 08:09:03 PM |
|
|