|
Published on Saturday, December 2, 2000 - 4:57am |
|
MILLER'S CROSSING review
Perfect cinema is a very rare thing. And the Coen Brothers are a very lucky pair because with MILLER’S CROSSING, they made… PERFECT CINEMA.
The most shocking thing though is how it went COMPLETELY unrecognized for Academy Awards, Golden Globes… etc. This was the year of DANCES WITH WOLVES, GOODFELLAS, GHOST, AWAKENINGS and GODFATHER III. The only film in the list that even deserves to vaguely be mentioned within the same paragraph with the Coen’s film is GOODFELLAS… but personally, I feel MILLER’S CROSSING is in an entirely different league.
Tonight at the Alamo Drafthouse perfection was unleashed on that screen I so love. MILLER’S CROSSING is a breathless film… an experience where as every line comes you are left in awe… throwaway lines that would be featured tag lines for other features… bristling with wit… shot with a perfect eye… music placed perfectly…
As I sat there tonight, after the DANNY BOY sequence, my cheeks were wet… not because a character I loved had suffered… not because of a poignant moment of associative experience… BUT because at that moment, with that scene… PERFECTION.
That same perfection I feel in CASABLANCA when the French Anthem is sung. That moment where Gene Kelly swings around the lamp post. Flynn and Rathbone as they duel in Technicolor throwing shadows upon that castle wall. Kong fighting the T-Rex. Indiana Jones and the trucks. Robert Shaw and the story of the Indianapolis. Fred and Ginger. Cagney and Ruby Keeler in Footlight Parade. Dick Powell waking up groggy in MURDER MY SWEET… Stallone’s run ending atop those bloody steps. You Ain’t Heard Nothing Yet. Jason and those blasted Skeletons. Max driving that tanker. Teardrops in the Rain. You know the moments for you…
Albert Finney has been transformed into an immortal with that song… that stogie… that Thompson… beneath that bed… leaping out the window… sigh, it is just PERFECT.
And as I sat there… excited, thrilled… Seeing a scene I’ve beheld numerous times… I felt my hands begin to clap, then my ears heard others… then came the cheers as I felt myself joining.
That audience recognizing and acknowledging perfection. Behind me on row three, I could feel the awe upon Quint and the Fair Spanish Lady. They were lucky enough to be seeing the film for their first time. Youth, and the joy of discovery.
Moments like these are why I find myself in theaters. The sheer exhilaration.
Walking out of MILLER’S CROSSING tonight I didn’t feel just pleased, I felt humbled. The level of writing is awe inspiring. And as we hit the lobby it was full of others talking to one another, and as I was headed to the head, the Fair Spanish Lady looks at me and asks, "How do you even start to make a movie that perfect?" Indeed.
Ya know this is one of those movies that quite honestly points out why AWARDS are wrong. You can’t give an award to the best film of a year, the year it comes out. You have to do it with distance.
Right now, where does DANCES WITH WOLVES or GHOST or AWAKENINGS or GODFATHER III or GOODFELLAS stand with you? Now watch MILLER’S CROSSING. Not one nomination? Heh. Right.
The Coen Brothers are my most treasured film artists working today. They embody the very joy of cinema that I love. Perfect writing. Perfect images. Perfect sound. And it is all put together so you don’t focus on any one of them… you see it all. And at the end of the journey they take me on, I’m invigorated.
Joel… Ethan… Bless you. I can’t wait to see everything you make for the duration of your lives. They provide that which theaters need to thrive. FILM in all its entertaining, thrilling and emotional bliss. God I love MILLER’S CROSSING.
"If I'd known we were gonna cast our feelings into words, I'd've memorized the Song of Solomon."
You tell em Tom!
Alright... ADDITIONAL THOUGHTS: I've seen a couple of the blind below claim that MILLER'S CROSSING is without soul... And I've noticed that noone is defending the film against these handicapped folk... Perhaps it is because many of the lovers of MILLER'S CROSSING figure that these folks are trolls, or that in defining what a soul in a film is... is beyond their ability for tooling sentences. I will valiantly attempt to shoot this criticism down.
First off, this 'MISSING SOUL' complaint is the very same comment we hear from a few while watching STANLEY KUBRICK film. Again I disagree.
In CLOCKWORK ORANGE... Alex is the soul of the film. An angry and disruptive spirit. But at the end when you take away his capacity for his pleasures... this evil monster is now a limp vessel. Sure he was a horribly flawed human, but now he is even less. Forbidden the thoughts of carnal pleasure... gone the feelings of joy that came with his sadism. Now he just wanders about. In THE SHINING... no soul? No way. Nicholson's entire descent into madness.. Shelley's frightened desperate protecting of her son... Mr Kick The Can's talk with Danny?
The soul in Kubrick's film is there... you just have to watch the film with your eyes wide open. The actors and characters are not emotionally wrought beings... they do not wear their thoughts on their sleeves. They are internalized beings. People that are private and do not make a showcase of themselves.
Alright, understood... I have yet to address the alleged missing soul of MILLER'S CROSSING, but I had to warm up... ok?
MILLER'S CROSSING has a complete and large soul. The film is... at its heart about Friendship and the respect friends give when that relationship has come to an end.
The film is about Tom and Leo. Everything else in the film emanates from this friendship. How do I know? Watch the beginning of the film... Leo tries to help Tom out of his debt, but Tom does not want to be beholden to Leo... not out of fear... but because their friendship isn't based on what the other can do for each other, but out of a mutual respect. Listen to the dialogue about trading BODY BLOWS... Leo says he can trade body blows with anyone in the city except Tom.... and that is because when coming to blows with Tom, he would lose even if he won. This is the price of friendship.
When Tom admits to the affair he's been having with Verna... he knows that at that moment he has ended the greatest friendship he has ever known. Even if they were to reconcile, he realizes that he has crossed the street in a friendship that you never cross. He's lost his friend's trust forever. He could pick up and leave, but he still loves his friend... sees him in danger. He must help his friend one last time... And then he will have to leave. He does this not out of debt... not because Leo will reward him... not because it will personally help him... But because his friend needed help... and even if their friendship was over... the feelings he has for Leo are not. He must leave with everything on an even plane... Like with free masons, they must part on the square.
There is more honest soul in this relationship and the entire purpose of this film than I dare say any film any of you can think of. The goodbye gift of a life long friendship come to an end. And if you can't see that, then the soul you see missing is your own.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reader Talkback
First but.. by ralphvz | Dec 2nd, 2000 05:13:29 AM | Jesus Tom! by TallScott | Dec 2nd, 2000 05:33:24 AM | Got to watch this in Film 020
class and it blew me away by Tall_Boy | Dec 2nd, 2000 05:48:22 AM | My favourite Coen film by Bluedog | Dec 2nd, 2000 05:49:55 AM | Hey Harry!! Want to really
appreciate Miller's Crossing? by Vance Castaway | Dec 2nd, 2000 06:22:04 AM | look in your heart... by Hotspur | Dec 2nd, 2000 07:20:12 AM | Magic Moments.... by jasper Stillwell | Dec 2nd, 2000 07:44:56 AM | yup by myfavouritesock | Dec 2nd, 2000 08:06:21 AM | Where's the DVD? by Shortcut | Dec 2nd, 2000 08:56:40 AM | Its about ethics... by houndog | Dec 2nd, 2000 09:17:56 AM | Whats the rumpus by gookin | Dec 2nd, 2000 09:30:51 AM | Kevin Costner by Uga | Dec 2nd, 2000 10:52:17 AM | MILLER'S CROSSING is my
favorite gangster movie. by Nordling | Dec 2nd, 2000 10:58:43 AM | i am impressed by bright | Dec 2nd, 2000 11:17:08 AM | It always starts with a good
story... by richardstern_200 | Dec 2nd, 2000 11:26:54 AM | Amazing film by Sonata | Dec 2nd, 2000 11:58:48 AM | A perfect movie, but where's
the heart? by rubycanoe | Dec 2nd, 2000 12:01:49 PM | agreed - great gangster film by Airchinapilot | Dec 2nd, 2000 12:54:07 PM | Some more *moments* by Randall Flagg | Dec 2nd, 2000 01:02:46 PM | Harry, I'm ashamed of you..... by Jarek | Dec 2nd, 2000 01:02:58 PM | Perfect moment, again from the
coens.... by Jarek | Dec 2nd, 2000 01:06:32 PM | best line by gombi | Dec 2nd, 2000 01:07:34 PM | Sorry harry.... by Jarek | Dec 2nd, 2000 01:07:49 PM | What no mention of the Big
Lebowski? by IAmLegolas | Dec 2nd, 2000 01:25:51 PM | best line by oh-Dawg | Dec 2nd, 2000 01:35:43 PM | there goes his hat again by ellroy | Dec 2nd, 2000 01:37:07 PM | "I'll show you the LIFE of the
mind." by PANIC NOW | Dec 2nd, 2000 02:22:24 PM | I agree with you, Harry.
"Miller's Crossing" is just
the best t by Tender Branson | Dec 2nd, 2000 03:16:39 PM | Blah blah blah blah by ArC | Dec 2nd, 2000 03:47:01 PM | what's the big deal? by Private Witt | Dec 2nd, 2000 04:07:15 PM | No Soul? by jasper Stillwell | Dec 2nd, 2000 06:59:36 PM | no soul? by HeywoodFloyd | Dec 2nd, 2000 07:13:14 PM | Why Coen Brother Movies are
Great by ToucanBob | Dec 2nd, 2000 07:19:43 PM | Long live the HUD! by Lenny Nero | Dec 2nd, 2000 07:47:07 PM | you wanna know injustice? i
couldn't study millers
crossing for by enigma | Dec 2nd, 2000 08:04:50 PM | best line of all by Randall Flagg | Dec 2nd, 2000 09:18:24 PM | Miller's Crossing-Few Got It
in 1990 by THEOperative | Dec 2nd, 2000 10:00:02 PM | GOODFELLAS BEST FILM OF THE
90"s BY FAR!!! by pjdignan75 | Dec 2nd, 2000 11:59:49 PM | Favorite line by sully'sfool | Dec 3rd, 2000 12:15:09 AM | Stitch thinks back... by Mr.Stitch | Dec 3rd, 2000 12:37:19 AM | Harry, you're dead-on by emorr | Dec 3rd, 2000 12:54:38 AM | If you like Miller's Crossing
& Favorite Line by ZetaMP3 | Dec 3rd, 2000 01:00:43 AM | Miller's is a fine movie,
but.... by elecam | Dec 3rd, 2000 01:18:57 AM | Take your flunkies and
dangle... by Guinness | Dec 3rd, 2000 02:05:20 AM | "If I'da known we'd be castin'
our feelin's inta words, I'da
mem by Andy Travis | Dec 3rd, 2000 02:56:48 AM | Didja know Nathan Arizona was
supposed to play Leo? by Andy Travis | Dec 3rd, 2000 03:06:29 AM | Count by ArC | Dec 3rd, 2000 03:39:17 AM | Alienated? by Brundle Fly | Dec 3rd, 2000 06:27:48 AM | I repeat... by Nordling | Dec 3rd, 2000 07:23:58 AM | more perfect moments by Inverness | Dec 3rd, 2000 10:06:15 AM | Best film, best line by jeffro | Dec 3rd, 2000 11:17:12 AM | Overrated by The Gline | Dec 3rd, 2000 11:33:13 AM | Hey, The Gline! by ArC | Dec 3rd, 2000 12:06:45 PM | Miller's Crossing rocks,
but... by Wee Willie | Dec 3rd, 2000 12:43:19 PM | gline- by HeywoodFloyd | Dec 3rd, 2000 01:06:53 PM | "Whassa matter...somebody hit
you?" by BlackLodger | Dec 3rd, 2000 02:47:02 PM | better than goodfellas? by MOVIE WRITER | Dec 3rd, 2000 06:57:17 PM | more good lines... by What'stheRumpus? | Dec 3rd, 2000 07:46:48 PM | you're right about soul, harry by joesnuff | Dec 3rd, 2000 10:35:15 PM | OUATIA by photopimp | Dec 4th, 2000 12:40:31 AM | I wouldn't call Miller's
Crossing a mob movie any more
than I wo by Andy Travis | Dec 4th, 2000 01:12:29 AM | Yes, I'm a "troll." by r_dimitri22 | Dec 4th, 2000 09:59:25 AM | Chickenshit Sell Out? by Brian D. | Dec 4th, 2000 10:05:58 AM | I hoped & prayed this
out-of-the-blue praise of
Miller's Crossin by BraveCapt. | Dec 4th, 2000 11:21:29 AM | D'oh - someone already quoted
that "walking in the rain"
line. O by BraveCapt. | Dec 4th, 2000 12:12:34 PM | "Would that be physically or
just a mental state?" by BlackBanana | Dec 4th, 2000 06:30:13 PM | About that DVD... by Drexl Aubuchon | Dec 4th, 2000 08:48:51 PM | Youse Fancypants, Alla Youse! by Third Policeman | Dec 4th, 2000 09:00:01 PM | it's the kiss off! by dinomartini | Dec 4th, 2000 09:08:03 PM | Elves by Shaft9876 | Dec 5th, 2000 12:57:02 AM | And one more quote--"They took
his hair, Tommy...Jeesus,
that's by Andy Travis | Dec 5th, 2000 02:55:37 AM | Millers Crossing's soul by Elvis Cole | Dec 5th, 2000 08:14:40 AM | Its clear what I am saying...
As mud by ILoveBFlicks | Dec 5th, 2000 11:30:07 PM | by SteelyMax | Dec 6th, 2000 01:13:01 PM | cinema reviews and cake by SteelyMax | Dec 6th, 2000 01:13:49 PM | Miller's Crossing by phaedrus0 | Dec 7th, 2000 09:08:13 AM | DO HORSES HAVE KNEE'S? by jonleeus | Dec 7th, 2000 03:45:58 PM | Milllers Crossing: the last
word? by fclegg | Dec 8th, 2000 07:51:49 PM | miller's crossing by greenlightscafe | Dec 8th, 2000 08:12:45 PM | O Brother is better, but MC
has the best scene ever by Monkeybuttpadje | Dec 9th, 2000 11:02:52 AM | Still an artist with a
Thompson by Lt. Torello | Dec 9th, 2000 08:20:37 PM | the schmatte kid by dubois | Dec 13th, 2000 08:24:04 PM | Goodfellas destroys Coens by Duke Ray | Dec 14th, 2000 01:18:41 AM | Sublime by kittycat | Dec 14th, 2000 12:34:58 PM | Havent Seen MC until Seen it
10 Times by jerky | Dec 14th, 2000 04:18:51 PM | Best Film Ever by Krillian | Dec 16th, 2000 02:26:25 PM | a theory by tnaifeh | Dec 20th, 2000 07:45:22 PM | thank you by lou breeze | Dec 20th, 2000 07:53:48 PM | Miller's Crossing by wrazzi | Dec 20th, 2000 08:18:35 PM | "Miller's Crossing" IS a
masterpeice! by mathquiz21 | Dec 25th, 2000 10:48:14 PM | Where the *@#%& is the DVD??? by mathquiz21 | Dec 25th, 2000 11:02:47 PM | Miller's Crossing by PhunkyP | Jan 23rd, 2001 11:45:49 PM | He, uh...he left by lou breeze | Jun 6th, 2001 07:10:58 PM | 10 out of 10. And the DVD is
where.....? by MadJackMcMad | Sep 10th, 2002 08:33:41 AM | My love muffin Gabe by Brimacombe | Jun 23rd, 2003 12:52:16 AM | Miller very good, however . .
. by mp1701a | Aug 7th, 2003 08:12:54 AM |
|
|