Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

A brief look at the EPISODE 2 rough cut as recently screened at ILM

Hey folks, Harry here... On December 14th, 2000 I received the email you'll find at the bottom of the page from a source purporting to be coming from within ILM. However, I had no way to confirm it, as internal screenings within the Lucasfilm Empire are extremely hush hush. So I decided to just bury the report pending confirmation. However, today I got an email about a story that appeared on IMDB that came originally from StarWars.Com from Mason:

Star Wars To Be Fleshed Out

George Lucas and editor Ben Burtt have completed a rough-cut version of Star Wars: Episode II Click Here , running about two hours long, Lucasfilm said in a statement reported on its Star Wars site Friday. The statement quoted producer Rick McCallum as saying that he has gone through several "emotional stages" while reviewing the preliminary film. "At times, you have to face the truth of what you didn't get and what you hoped for," McCallum said. "The second stage is that you're amazed by all the things you did get that you didn't even think you got. And then the third stage is that you see certain things are infinitely better than you could have even imagined." McCallum says that Lucas recently screened the first half of the film to the special-effects team at Industrial Light & Magic. "It's the first time George has gone through every single scene," McCallum remarked. "ILM is ready to pounce on this."

Now, the weird bit of confusion is where McCallum is saying that George screened the first half of the film... but then goes on to say that it is the first time George went through every single scene.... Hmmmm.... Well, the original December 14th report I got in painted a similar picture but saying the actual time length of the cut at 2 1/2 hours. Is EPISODE 2 in dire trouble right now? Well, you have to understand first that George Lucas works in a very odd sort of filmmaking manner. He doesn't do it like regular filmmakers.... This is an extreme... almost ANIMATED FILM rough draft. Some characters are not even on camera to deliver their lines... and so much of the film is a work of blue screen that it is hard to discern any real sense of quality at this point... I have heard rumblings that there might be a delay in release for the film, but... as it is, ILM has over a year and a half to finish EPISODE II, so we'll just have to wait and see.... It is interesting that McCallum is acknowledging the disappointment at how the screening went... at least they are not in denial, I hope they pull it off.... here is Anon....

I must keep this brief for obvious reasons...We were recently given a screening of the film, EPISODE 2 (still no title) so far at ILM. 2 1/2 hours of rough effects work / plates and selected takes, etc; will be heavy on CGI. All I will say for now is that George and Rick are"stressing" over a major reworking of the storyline. It's putting deadlines back and makes our work extremely frustrating. There are whispers that Spielberg is coming on board to help with the editing and story. It's a total shambles! Everyone wants another Empire Strikes Back......the team is aware of this, but we're a long way off.

-- anon

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

first?
by kofman
Dec 28th, 2000
02:03:00 AM
Oh please.
by Tanith M
Dec 28th, 2000
02:05:42 AM
(holding face in hands with tears seeping through my fingers...)
by Mully4Ever
Dec 28th, 2000
02:07:56 AM
The Force
by slav
Dec 28th, 2000
02:10:05 AM
good news
by masse
Dec 28th, 2000
02:32:28 AM
This is blatantly false.
by Laura17
Dec 28th, 2000
04:08:24 AM
Rain
by slav
Dec 28th, 2000
04:23:55 AM
And I heard half the film is out of focus!
by jarjar_dinks
Dec 28th, 2000
04:39:17 AM
have faith people
by Zombie Vig
Dec 28th, 2000
04:57:12 AM
There can only be one
by Biggus_Dikkus
Dec 28th, 2000
05:05:12 AM
Alarmist crap...
by PoxyVonSinister
Dec 28th, 2000
05:16:11 AM
Spielberg's involvement
by Nucleus777
Dec 28th, 2000
05:21:32 AM
Are you guys that short of memory?
by PKD
Dec 28th, 2000
05:21:38 AM
RICK
by Stormdancer
Dec 28th, 2000
05:29:22 AM
A Bowl of Fuck. . .
by RenoNevada2000
Dec 28th, 2000
05:38:45 AM
Harry is shameless
by B A Fett
Dec 28th, 2000
06:00:44 AM
star was
by sinus
Dec 28th, 2000
06:05:42 AM
It's BS, but at least . . .
by Drath
Dec 28th, 2000
06:06:08 AM
Kids with computers (RE: AE)
by Beowulf Prime
Dec 28th, 2000
06:45:08 AM
So go post on a Matrix board, Cameo
by Laura17
Dec 28th, 2000
06:54:25 AM
5-7-5
by Hi-Koo
Dec 28th, 2000
06:54:58 AM
come on...
by Key_Card
Dec 28th, 2000
07:00:05 AM
Conflicts in McCallum report and "ILM Guy" report
by Brian 2000
Dec 28th, 2000
07:07:52 AM
AE
by Key_Card
Dec 28th, 2000
07:18:30 AM
Anyone who works in film knows...
by Wee Willie
Dec 28th, 2000
07:28:26 AM
Viscious Circle
by sora1
Dec 28th, 2000
07:33:45 AM
Episode II teaser trailer
by Pippin's Diamond
Dec 28th, 2000
07:44:35 AM
AE...
by Key_Card
Dec 28th, 2000
07:51:52 AM
secret shoppers
by rogerboxlightner
Dec 28th, 2000
08:07:22 AM
Please eat a bowl of fuck...Berserker!
by scudd
Dec 28th, 2000
08:27:02 AM
Some concerns....and a dream come true.
by RobinP
Dec 28th, 2000
08:43:32 AM
Re: Battleposter, that was some funny sh*t!!!
by RMcCallum
Dec 28th, 2000
08:46:35 AM
Writin'
by Kent_Grattan
Dec 28th, 2000
08:47:00 AM
Hopes are High for Episode 2
by QuizKidDonnie
Dec 28th, 2000
08:51:59 AM
$tar War$
by Captain BenSisko
Dec 28th, 2000
09:00:15 AM
YOU'RE ALL WHACKed
by Mundane Noodle
Dec 28th, 2000
09:03:44 AM
Come HERE, TALK-DROID!!...
by Pizza The Hut
Dec 28th, 2000
09:05:23 AM
Has anyone else seen that freaky-ass wampa animation at starwars
by Blue Devil
Dec 28th, 2000
09:07:19 AM
whatever, stud
by Sled-Head
Dec 28th, 2000
09:43:49 AM
You people are really hypocritical
by tokyokiller
Dec 28th, 2000
09:48:13 AM
Beowulf prime
by Dragonfire
Dec 28th, 2000
10:34:59 AM
Couldn't this just be a well-calculated move?
by Toe Jam
Dec 28th, 2000
11:03:13 AM
I think Lucas et al. should show the rough cut to select SW fan
by ARCTURUS
Dec 28th, 2000
11:19:33 AM
It is too early to tell so relax!!!!
by Jedi 7
Dec 28th, 2000
11:20:10 AM
darth_bolgna
by darth_law
Dec 28th, 2000
11:28:18 AM
Forget Spielberg I got the Smart Solution right here...
by Bari Umenema
Dec 28th, 2000
12:05:48 PM
Ep. III poster (fake, tho. I made it for a school final)
by Jopapa
Dec 28th, 2000
12:13:00 PM

by :-
Dec 28th, 2000
12:39:58 PM
Sheeshh..........
by :-
Dec 28th, 2000
12:40:44 PM
You can't actually being take this crap seriously...
by Some Young Guy
Dec 28th, 2000
12:43:08 PM
Good, Bad, Ugly... We need MORE!
by scifi_addict
Dec 28th, 2000
12:46:11 PM

by JasonW
Dec 28th, 2000
12:52:31 PM
BS
by Boba Fart
Dec 28th, 2000
12:56:56 PM
Like an Animated film? Let Miyazaki direct Episode 3!
by Asmodeus
Dec 28th, 2000
01:15:46 PM
what it's worth
by scanlon
Dec 28th, 2000
01:17:18 PM
Err hello.....reality check required I think...
by Gabba-UK
Dec 28th, 2000
01:17:31 PM
Spielberg
by TurboMonkey
Dec 28th, 2000
01:18:18 PM
Seriously AICN, what is the deal?
by Brian 2000
Dec 28th, 2000
01:23:38 PM
Oh, no!
by DrLogan
Dec 28th, 2000
02:21:33 PM
George, go back to your fucking roots!
by Dwight Frye
Dec 28th, 2000
02:28:18 PM
Something Strange is going on...
by MOSDEF
Dec 28th, 2000
02:37:59 PM
This is all so very, very silly...
by Wallace Nussbaum
Dec 28th, 2000
02:42:05 PM
R E A C T I O N A R Y
by Dark Clown
Dec 28th, 2000
02:48:25 PM
who said eat a bowl of fuck?
by mattevil
Dec 28th, 2000
02:58:49 PM
Not to mention the 40 min. of fuzzy footage!!
by lisa
Dec 28th, 2000
03:03:08 PM
Oh please
by Agent-23
Dec 28th, 2000
03:06:36 PM
Wow, a neg. Star Wars post on Harry's site???
by lisa
Dec 28th, 2000
03:20:08 PM
GREAT SCOOP HARRY!! Do you think Lucas will place a gag order on
by EL Duderino
Dec 28th, 2000
03:53:32 PM
This is NOT a crisis, folks!
by Wilbur
Dec 28th, 2000
04:03:04 PM
Those were the days, my friends
by tenpercent
Dec 28th, 2000
04:18:21 PM
yaaawwwwnnnn.
by half vader
Dec 28th, 2000
04:27:59 PM
www.filmaction.com
by Wee Willie
Dec 28th, 2000
05:15:55 PM
LOTR and Star Wars
by MOSDEF
Dec 28th, 2000
05:24:22 PM
Gosh, it's the different opinions like these, you wonder why Luc
by themightyra
Dec 28th, 2000
05:41:59 PM
This is a hoax!
by Blue Devil
Dec 28th, 2000
05:51:19 PM
LOSERS!
by mcrbids
Dec 28th, 2000
07:38:34 PM
I'm George Lucas, trust me... I know what I'm doing
by GeorgeLucas
Dec 28th, 2000
08:48:23 PM
Episode III - birds eye view
by Shapethrower
Dec 28th, 2000
10:20:10 PM
oh my god!!!!!!
by Tyrant X
Dec 28th, 2000
10:29:58 PM
"Do or do not. There is no try."
by darthpablo
Dec 28th, 2000
10:34:16 PM
Good god man ...
by daedalusai
Dec 28th, 2000
10:54:15 PM
I doth decree this to be BULLSHITE!
by Tall_Boy
Dec 29th, 2000
12:16:54 AM
Episode 2 or Episode Poo?
by Kevmac
Dec 29th, 2000
04:27:30 AM
Just Go Here
by shadowtalk
Dec 29th, 2000
04:48:51 AM
"Hear you nothing that I say? Clear your mind of questions"
by Centuryslayer
Dec 29th, 2000
05:21:43 AM
STAR WARS
by joemannix
Dec 29th, 2000
08:09:13 AM
DuHeeeeeaaaaa
by Stimpson J Cat
Dec 29th, 2000
09:02:41 AM
cheapphish
by Dragonfire
Dec 29th, 2000
09:59:19 AM
Rule #1
by Skeptic Ogre
Dec 29th, 2000
11:30:10 AM
This report is bullshit
by NightTraveler
Dec 29th, 2000
02:05:16 PM
This report is a big pile of steaming shit...
by JMYoda
Dec 29th, 2000
02:05:22 PM
This report is bullshit
by NightTraveler
Dec 29th, 2000
02:09:57 PM
The Matrix is a great flick but...
by JMYoda
Dec 29th, 2000
02:24:47 PM
Test Screening?
by Wee Willie
Dec 29th, 2000
02:25:41 PM
Episode II is gonna be great
by Whoppner
Dec 29th, 2000
04:43:55 PM
The good old days
by Gasgano
Dec 29th, 2000
05:27:43 PM
Has lucas no pride or dignety anymore????
by Gentle_Fury
Dec 29th, 2000
06:18:57 PM
When George Screen The Rough Cut For Me...
by Buzz Maverik
Dec 29th, 2000
08:57:06 PM
stick to the facts
by NuteG
Dec 30th, 2000
02:12:53 AM
This news sounds like a bunch of crap
by Seany
Dec 30th, 2000
10:18:04 AM
I agree with Mad Eye Moody
by Whoppner
Dec 30th, 2000
12:34:16 PM
The House the Star Wars Fans Built: Lucas and half-eaten Burger
by JetJaguar
Dec 30th, 2000
12:35:22 PM
Oh yeah, Mad Eye Moody....
by JetJaguar
Dec 30th, 2000
12:40:26 PM
Oh yeah...
by JetJaguar
Dec 30th, 2000
12:45:24 PM
Something you wish to share with group JetJaguar???
by Gabba-UK
Dec 30th, 2000
02:56:43 PM
Martix fans should just shut the fuck up!
by Gaz
Dec 30th, 2000
04:46:03 PM
Yes, yes, yes, we are all gods...
by RoyFokker
Dec 30th, 2000
04:56:48 PM
AARGH!! MEESUM'S GETTING BAKED TO DELICATE CRUNCH!!
by iloveryan
Dec 30th, 2000
06:43:38 PM
I'm so fucking sick of people dissing Mark Hamill
by JMYoda
Dec 30th, 2000
07:43:20 PM
I SAY
by Tyrant X
Dec 30th, 2000
09:12:44 PM
Who would have thought trying to insert dignity into the script
by LSHB
Dec 30th, 2000
09:33:49 PM
And people who post with ALL CAPS aren't all that bright eithe
by JMYoda
Dec 31st, 2000
12:50:19 AM
Laura17 don't listen to the jerks...
by JMYoda
Dec 31st, 2000
01:26:50 AM
Um... Wee Willie...
by Psyclops
Dec 31st, 2000
02:17:17 AM
news service
by NuteG
Dec 31st, 2000
02:57:26 AM
Spielberg isn't good for SW
by Rebel Nut
Dec 31st, 2000
05:09:03 AM
Re. Spielberg is not good for SW
by NuteG
Dec 31st, 2000
07:32:12 AM
Mark Hamill and acting
by Whoppner
Dec 31st, 2000
07:54:02 AM
Maybe this negativity is good
by Selig74
Dec 31st, 2000
08:30:27 AM
Gabba-UK
by JetJaguar
Dec 31st, 2000
11:03:57 PM
George directing someone to the bathroom.
by w5h
Dec 31st, 2000
11:45:42 PM
George owes us nothing
by NuteG
Jan 1st, 2001
11:15:42 AM
Spielberg did say something like that
by Selig74
Jan 1st, 2001
12:29:14 PM
Lucas *did* hire outside writer--Jonathan Hales
by Laura17
Jan 1st, 2001
01:01:56 PM
Mad obsesive's....
by Gabba-UK
Jan 1st, 2001
01:39:44 PM
relax, it's just a frickin' movie!
by CyberMark
Jan 1st, 2001
11:59:35 PM
Star Wars 2
by Frehley
Jan 2nd, 2001
12:06:09 AM
Comments on the recent news.
by Vader75
Jan 2nd, 2001
02:38:39 AM
Yeah right...
by EmptyG
Jan 2nd, 2001
10:42:08 AM
Oh gimme a break
by EmptyG
Jan 2nd, 2001
10:48:19 AM
Late....but what the hell
by Tanka -d2
Jan 2nd, 2001
02:28:54 PM
Lucas owes us - 2nd attempt
by NuteG
Jan 3rd, 2001
11:13:15 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.